Best Pies in Atlanta: Top 20 Sweet & Savory Spots (2025)
Last Updated: October 2025 | Reading Time: 12 minutes
Looking for the best pies in Atlanta? Whether you’re craving classic Southern pecan pie, savory chicken pot pie, or unique artisan creations, Atlanta’s dessert and bakery scene delivers exceptional pies across every neighborhood. This comprehensive guide features 20 must-try pies from Inman Park to Decatur, including sweet dessert pies, hearty savory options, and vegan alternatives.
Quick Navigation:
Sweet Dessert Pies That’ll Rock Your World
1. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop – Classic Southern Buttermilk Pie
Location: Multiple Atlanta locations
Specialty: Personal-sized Southern pies
Price Range: $-$$
This Atlanta-based pie chain specializes in individual-sized pies perfect for personal indulgence. Their signature buttermilk pie features a sweet, tangy custard filling with a perfectly balanced flavor profile. The creamy texture and traditional Southern recipe make this a must-try for anyone exploring Atlanta’s dessert scene.
Pro tip: Order the mini size for portion control, though these addictive pies make it tempting to eat the whole thing.
Best for: Southern pie traditionalists, gift-giving, office treats
2. Proof Bakeshop – Seasonal Fruit Pies
Location: Inman Park
Specialty: Artisan pastries and seasonal desserts
Price Range: $$-$$$
Proof Bakeshop has earned a reputation as one of Atlanta’s premier bakeries, and their fruit pies showcase why. The exceptionally buttery, flaky crust provides the perfect foundation for seasonal fillings—think peak Georgia peaches in summer and crisp apples in fall.
Seasonal availability: Peach pie (June-August), Apple pie (September-November), Berry pies (May-July)
Best for: Special occasions, pie purists, seasonal eating enthusiasts
3. Alon’s Bakery – French Apple Tart
Location: Dunwoody
Specialty: European-style pastries
Price Range: $$-$$$
Alon’s Bakery brings European sophistication to Atlanta’s bakery scene. Their French apple tart features paper-thin apple slices arranged in beautiful concentric circles over almond cream (frangipane), creating both visual appeal and complex flavor.
What makes it special: The almond cream base adds nutty richness that distinguishes this from traditional American apple pie.
Best for: Elegant dinner parties, French pastry lovers, Instagram-worthy desserts
4. The Pie Hole – Bourbon Pecan Pie
Location: Ponce City Market
Specialty: Creative pie flavors
Price Range: $$
Traditional pecan pie gets an adult upgrade with bourbon at this popular Ponce City Market bakery. The addition of Kentucky bourbon enhances the caramelized pecan filling, creating a sophisticated take on this Southern classic dessert.
Alcohol content: Contains bourbon (not suitable for children)
Best for: Bourbon lovers, Southern food enthusiasts, holiday desserts
5. Home Grown – Mile-High Meringue Pie
Location: Reynoldstown & East Atlanta Village
Specialty: Farm-to-table Southern comfort food
Price Range: $$
Home Grown serves towering meringue pies that are as photogenic as they are delicious. Choose from lemon meringue, chocolate meringue, or coconut cream—each featuring impressively tall, perfectly toasted meringue.
Flavor options: Lemon, chocolate, coconut cream
Best for: Meringue lovers, Instagram content, sharing (these are huge!)
6. Little Tart Bakeshop – Chess Pie
Location: Grant Park
Specialty: Southern baked goods
Price Range: $-$$
This charming neighborhood bakery serves authentic Southern chess pie—a simple custard pie with a caramelized top that’s been a Southern staple for generations. Little Tart’s version honors tradition while maintaining consistently excellent execution.
What is chess pie? A Southern custard pie made with eggs, butter, sugar, and a small amount of flour, creating a unique texture that’s both creamy and slightly firm.
Best for: Southern food history buffs, simple pleasures, afternoon coffee pairing
7. Sublime Doughnuts – Key Lime Pie
Location: Multiple Atlanta locations
Specialty: Gourmet doughnuts and desserts
Price Range: $-$$
Sublime Doughnuts proves their dessert expertise extends beyond doughnuts with this tangy, creamy key lime pie. The graham cracker crust stays perfectly crisp, and the filling achieves that ideal balance of tart and sweet.
Fun fact: Key lime pie is Florida’s official state pie, but Atlanta does it justice!
Best for: Citrus lovers, summer desserts, doughnut shop discoveries
8. Ria’s Bluebird – Blueberry Pie
Location: Grant Park
Specialty: Homestyle Southern cooking
Price Range: $$
Ria’s Bluebird delivers homestyle blueberry pie with a gorgeous lattice crust and filling bursting with fresh blueberries. This is the kind of pie that tastes like it came from your grandmother’s kitchen—in the best possible way.
Seasonal note: Best in summer when Georgia blueberries are at peak freshness
Best for: Classic American pie lovers, summer desserts, nostalgic comfort food
9. The General Muir – Chocolate Cream Pie
Location: Emory Point
Specialty: Jewish deli classics
Price Range: $$-$$$
The General Muir brings New York deli excellence to Atlanta, including their decadent chocolate cream pie. Rich chocolate custard filling topped with real whipped cream creates an indulgent dessert that chocolate lovers dream about.
What sets it apart: Real whipped cream (not Cool Whip) and high-quality chocolate
Best for: Chocolate enthusiasts, deli meal finales, special treats
10. Tassili’s Raw Reality – Raw Vegan Key Lime Pie
Location: West End & Little Five Points
Specialty: Raw vegan cuisine
Price Range: $$
Tassili’s Raw Reality proves that vegan and raw desserts can be genuinely delicious. Made with cashews and dates, this key lime pie delivers surprising creaminess and authentic lime flavor without dairy or baking.
Dietary info: Vegan, gluten-free, raw, refined sugar-free
Best for: Vegan diners, health-conscious dessert lovers, dietary restrictions
11. Revolution Doughnuts – Banana Cream Pie
Location: Decatur
Specialty: Artisan doughnuts and pastries
Price Range: $-$$
Another doughnut shop proving their pastry prowess, Revolution Doughnuts creates banana cream pie with fresh bananas, vanilla custard, whipped cream, and a flaky crust. It’s comfort food elevated to art.
Texture profile: Creamy custard, fresh banana slices, light whipped cream, crispy crust
Best for: Banana lovers, comfort food cravings, Decatur food tours
12. Sweet Auburn Bread Company – Sweet Potato Pie
Location: Ponce City Market
Specialty: Southern heritage baking
Price Range: $$
Sweet Auburn Bread Company celebrates Southern heritage with their velvety sweet potato pie, perfectly spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, and vanilla. This Thanksgiving classic is available year-round for those who don’t want to wait for the holidays.
Cultural significance: Sweet potato pie is a beloved African American Southern dessert tradition
Best for: Southern soul food lovers, Thanksgiving flavors year-round, spice enthusiasts
Savory Sensations: When Dinner Comes in Pie Form
13. Bantam + Biddy – Chicken Pot Pie
Location: Ansley Mall
Specialty: Rotisserie chicken dishes
Price Range: $$-$$$
Bantam + Biddy elevates the classic chicken pot pie with rotisserie chicken, fresh vegetables, creamy filling, and flaky puff pastry. This is comfort food at its finest—perfect for Atlanta’s cooler months.
Serving size: Generous portions, great for sharing or a hearty meal
Best for: Comfort food cravings, cold weather dining, chicken lovers
14. The Albert – Steak and Ale Pie
Location: Inman Park
Specialty: British gastropub fare
Price Range: $$-$$$
The Albert brings authentic British pub food to Atlanta, including traditional steak and ale pie. Tender beef in rich, savory gravy wrapped in golden pastry pairs perfectly with a pint of beer.
British authenticity: Made with traditional recipes and techniques from the UK
Best for: British food enthusiasts, beer pairings, hearty dinners
15. Grana – Tomato Pie
Location: Inman Park
Specialty: Italian-Southern fusion
Price Range: $$-$$$
Grana creates a stunning tomato pie featuring heirloom tomatoes, fresh basil, and cheese on flaky crust. This Southern-Italian hybrid showcases peak summer produce in pie form.
Seasonal availability: Best in summer with fresh heirloom tomatoes
Best for: Tomato lovers, summer dining, vegetarian options
16. Brick Store Pub – Shepherd’s Pie
Location: Decatur
Specialty: Irish pub classics
Price Range: $$
Brick Store Pub serves authentic shepherd’s pie made with seasoned lamb, vegetables, and creamy mashed potato topping crisped to perfection. This Irish classic provides stick-to-your-ribs satisfaction.
Traditional note: True shepherd’s pie uses lamb; cottage pie uses beef
Best for: Irish food lovers, beer pairings, winter comfort food
17. Arden’s Garden – Vegetable Pot Pie
Location: Multiple Atlanta locations
Specialty: Health-focused cafe fare
Price Range: $$
Arden’s Garden offers wholesome vegetable pot pie packed with seasonal vegetables in herb-infused sauce. This lighter take on pot pie doesn’t sacrifice flavor for nutrition.
Dietary info: Vegetarian, can often accommodate vegan requests
Best for: Vegetarians, health-conscious diners, lighter comfort food
18. The Colonnade – Chicken Pot Pie
Location: Cheshire BridgeSpecialty: Classic Southern comfort foodPrice Range: $-$$
The Colonnade has been an Atlanta institution since 1927, perfecting their chicken pot pie recipe for nearly a century. This is old-school Southern cooking at its most authentic.
Historical significance: One of Atlanta’s oldest continuously operating restaurants
Best for: Atlanta food history, traditional Southern cooking, nostalgia
Wild Cards: Pies That Break the Rules (In the Best Way)
19. Hodgepodge Coffeehouse – Peanut Butter Pie
Location: East Atlanta Village
Specialty: Quirky coffeehouse treats
Price Range: $-$$
This neighborhood cafe serves decadent peanut butter pie with chocolate cookie crust and fluffy peanut butter filling. It’s rich, indulgent, and absolutely worth any sugar coma.
Allergy warning: Contains peanuts (obviously!)
Best for: Peanut butter fanatics, coffee shop discoveries, indulgent treats
20. Muchacho – Mexican Chocolate Pie
Location: Grant Park
Specialty: Mexican-inspired cuisine
Price Range: $$
Muchacho creates unique Mexican chocolate pie featuring cinnamon, cayenne, and just enough spice to keep things interesting. The balance of sweet and heat reimagines chocolate pie entirely.
Spice level: Mild heat that enhances rather than overwhelms
Best for: Adventurous eaters, chocolate with a twist, unique desserts
Your Pie-Hunting Game Plan
Essential Tips for Atlanta Pie Seekers
Call Ahead for Availability
Popular pies sell out quickly, especially on weekends. Call before visiting to avoid disappointment, particularly for specialty flavors.
Embrace Seasonal Offerings
Many Atlanta bakeries rotate pie flavors based on seasonal produce:
- Spring: Strawberry, rhubarb
- Summer: Peach, blueberry, blackberry
- Fall: Apple, pumpkin, sweet potato
- Winter: Pecan, chess, chocolate
Order Whole Pies in Advance
Planning a party or celebration? Most bakeries require 24-48 hours notice for whole pie orders. This ensures freshness and availability.
Explore by Neighborhood
Use this pie guide as an excuse to discover different Atlanta neighborhoods. Each area offers unique character alongside delicious pies.
Best Atlanta Neighborhoods for Pie Lovers
Inman Park: The Pie Paradise
Featured pies: Proof Bakeshop (seasonal fruit pies), The Albert (steak and ale pie), Grana (tomato pie)
Inman Park leads Atlanta’s pie scene with three exceptional options within walking distance. This historic neighborhood combines Victorian architecture with cutting-edge food culture.
Bonus: Explore the Atlanta BeltLine Eastside Trail while you’re here.
Grant Park: Charming & Delicious
Featured pies: Little Tart Bakeshop (chess pie), Ria’s Bluebird (blueberry pie), Muchacho (Mexican chocolate pie)
Grant Park offers three distinct pie experiences in one charming neighborhood. Visit Zoo Atlanta and grab pie afterward.
Ponce City Market: Food Hall Heaven
Featured pies: The Pie Hole (bourbon pecan pie), Sweet Auburn Bread Company (sweet potato pie)
Ponce City Market provides two excellent pie options plus dozens of other food vendors. This converted Sears building is now Atlanta’s premier food destination.
East Atlanta Village: Quirky & Cool
Featured pies: Home Grown (mile-high meringue pie), Hodgepodge Coffeehouse (peanut butter pie)
East Atlanta Village brings eclectic vibes and creative pies. This neighborhood is known for its independent spirit and excellent food scene.
Frequently Asked Questions About Atlanta Pies
What is the most popular pie in Atlanta?Pecan pie and sweet potato pie are Southern classics that remain extremely popular. For modern favorites, seasonal fruit pies from Proof Bakeshop and buttermilk pie from Buttermilk Sky consistently rank highest.
Where can I find vegan pie in Atlanta?Tassili’s Raw Reality offers excellent raw vegan pies. Many bakeries also accommodate vegan requests with advance notice.
What neighborhoods have the best pie shops?Inman Park, Grant Park, and Ponce City Market offer the highest concentration of excellent pie options within walking distance.
Can I order whole pies for Thanksgiving?Yes! Most bakeries accept Thanksgiving pie orders but require 1-2 weeks advance notice during the holiday season. Order early for best selection.
Are these pies available year-round?Some pies are seasonal (particularly fruit pies), while classics like pecan, chocolate, and chess pie are typically available year-round. Call ahead to confirm.
The Final Slice
Atlanta’s pie scene proves our city takes food seriously—whether honoring Southern traditions or pushing creative boundaries. From family recipes passed down through generations to innovative flavor combinations, there’s a pie for everyone in Atlanta.
These 20 pies represent the best of Atlanta’s dessert and savory pie offerings across multiple neighborhoods. Whether you’re a local looking for your next favorite spot or a visitor exploring Atlanta’s food scene, this guide provides a delicious roadmap.
Ready to start your pie adventure? Grab your stretchy pants, rally your fellow pie enthusiasts, and start checking off this list. Your taste buds are about to go on the adventure of a lifetime.
Remember: Life is short, eat the pie! 🥧
Related Atlanta Food Guides
- Best Restaurants in Inman Park
- Ponce City Market Complete Guide
- Atlanta BeltLine Restaurant Guide
- Best Brunch Spots in Atlanta
About The Atlanta Guide: Your trusted local resource for exploring Atlanta’s neighborhoods, restaurants, culture, and hidden gems. Visit our homepage for more Atlanta guides.
Share your favorite Atlanta pie in the comments below! We’re always looking for our next slice of heaven and love hearing from fellow pie enthusiasts.
